4

Problem: There's been a lot of edits being approved due to question retagging. Every time these edits are done, these questions go to the pm.se frontpage as latest activity, "burying" several other, actual newer or active questions. Would it be a nuisance from a community perspective?

Background: As of today, there's 4 different tags for MS Project:

besides the "parent" tag.

Are there enough users using them as specific filters either to search for questions or provide answers or are they used mainly to clearly specify the software version the question is about? There's a request for 2013 tag creation from around an year ago, so I assume they are used somehow.

I see a few approaches:

  • Do nothing. It's not a problem, after all.
  • Avoid usage of version-specific tags.
  • Avoid massive tagging.
  • Avoid massive tag approval (when tagging is done by users with low rep)

Any other better ideas?

  • 2
    Specificity is useful. Over-specificity is probably irrelevant. If the version matters, maybe we should clarify the use of the umbrella tag, or burninate it. – Todd A. Jacobs Nov 10 '18 at 12:56
  • For the people like me who hadn't heard about burninate... What does it mean to “burninate” a tag? :) – Tiago Cardoso Nov 10 '18 at 15:20
  • Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat. – Tiago Cardoso Nov 10 '18 at 15:28
  • FYI, just used these comments for the sake of creating a room, something I'd be done regardless of comments (to summon specific involved people for discussion) :) – Tiago Cardoso Nov 10 '18 at 15:29
4

Tags Updated

There was a discussion about this in chat. After a little back-and-forth, I made some changes that will hopefully resolve this without a ton of extra work for the PMSE community.

  1. I've updated the tag to indicate that it's for stuff that doesn't already have a specific tag.
  2. I've updated to indicate when the top-level tag should be used, and when version-specific tags should be used instead.
  3. The tag also lists the available set of version-specific Project tags, so people don't need to go searching for them. Currently, these tags are:

Ongoing Community Actions

People should feel free to retag questions they come across to fit the community's current guidelines, and to keep the tag wikis up to date. By doing your part to keep tags relevant, you're helping to improve search and prevent "topic ghettos."

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .