5

First, the question you should be asking is "Is there a consensus among the community", not moderators, as it is the community here who runs this site. Diamond moderators are here to handle exceptional circumstances. The 5 users who voted to close your post are all users of Project Management Stack Exchange who have contributed enough to gain the ...


4

The Community Account is Automated Community♦ is a system account, not a person. Issues with how that account functions should probably be brought up on Stack Exchange Meta instead of here. Your Post I'm not a moderator or an op, so I can't tell you exactly how your question was scheduled for deletion, but I can shed some light on why it was closed. It ...


3

TL;DR Product management as it relates to project management is certainly on-topic here, but other aspects of product or portfolio management are out of scope. In particular, the roles and responsibilities of a Product Manager within a given project-management framework are likely to be very much within the scope of this site. Analysis of Your Referenced ...


2

SE Sites Have Community-Developed Norms and Values Part of your issue is that you aren't understanding that that PMSE (like most SE sites) has both a community culture and a set of norms that have evolved over time. As much as we can, we document these in the help section, but like any social group some of these things are simply "tribal knowledge" ...


1

With just slight variations in the working culture (do people get tasks assigned, or do they pull from a backlog), the scope of the work considered when writing the answer and the expertise of the involved people, I would be able to write two completely valid and opposing answers. And only if you had a preconceived notion of what answer you want to hear ...


1

TL;DR Technically, yes. However, for a number of reasons outlined below, I'd like to see this particular question remain closed, and the heavily edited question the OP inspired the community to create should be moved to a new question. Reasons Not to Re-Open The OP didn't actually edit the question, but you can see how the community modified the question ...


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible